How to Replace a Kitchen Sink Strainer Like a Pro (2026 Guide)

Guides & TipsBy SabreenUpdated 7 min read

Kitchen Bath Picks is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

In this guide
  1. Why the kitchen sink strainer matters
  2. Signs you need to replace your kitchen sink strainer
  3. Types of kitchen sink strainers
  4. Choosing a kitchen sink strainer material
  5. How to remove a stuck kitchen sink strainer
  6. Tools and materials
  7. How to replace a kitchen sink strainer step by step
  8. Best kitchen sink strainer parts and tools
  9. Troubleshooting a leaking kitchen sink strainer
  10. How to keep your kitchen sink strainer working
  11. Kitchen sink strainer FAQs
  12. Final thoughts

The sink strainer is the metal basket and drain body sitting in the bottom of your kitchen sink. It catches food scraps, lets you plug the sink for washing dishes and forms the watertight seal between the sink and the drain pipes. When it starts leaking underneath, the basket won’t seal, or the finish is pitted and rusty, replacing the kitchen sink strainer is an inexpensive fix that takes about an hour.

This 2026 guide explains the types of strainers, the tools you need and how to replace a kitchen sink strainer step by step so it seals properly the first time.

Quick answer: Disconnect the tailpiece under the sink, unscrew the large locknut holding the strainer body with a sink drain wrench or pliers, and push the old strainer up and out. Clean the sink opening, press a rope of plumber’s putty under the new strainer’s flange, set it in the hole, and tighten the gasket, friction ring and locknut from below. Reconnect the tailpiece, wipe away excess putty and test for leaks.

How to replace a kitchen sink strainer
A new kitchen sink strainer stops leaks and improves drainage.

Why the kitchen sink strainer matters

  • Protects pipes: it catches food scraps and utensils that would otherwise clog the drain trap.
  • Lets you fill the sink: the basket or stopper seals the drain for soaking dishes.
  • Seals the drain: the putty and gaskets keep water from leaking into the cabinet.

Signs you need to replace your kitchen sink strainer

  • Water drips from under the sink near the drain body, especially when the sink is full
  • The basket no longer holds water when closed
  • Rust, pitting or a worn finish on the strainer
  • A loose strainer body that moves when you push on it
  • Cracked or broken baskets or stoppers

Types of kitchen sink strainers

TypeHow it worksBest for
Locknut strainerLarge threaded nut holds the body from belowMost kitchen sinks; strong seal
Retainer (three-screw) strainerScrews tighten a retainer ring under the sinkTight spaces; easier tightening
Twist-lock basketBasket twists to seal and strainEveryday convenience
Post-style basket (e.g. Duostrainer)Center post lifts or drops the stopperEasy one-hand sealing
Disposal flangeMounts a garbage disposal insteadSinks with disposals

Most kitchen sinks have a standard 3-1/2 inch drain opening, and most strainers have a 1-1/2 inch outlet. Check your sink’s opening and whether you want a strainer with a tailpiece included.

Choosing a kitchen sink strainer material

Strainer bodies come in a few materials, and the choice affects how long the seal and finish last.

  • Solid brass with chrome or other plating: the most durable option, resistant to cracking and easy to tighten firmly. A good long-term choice for busy kitchens.
  • Stainless steel: resists rust and matches stainless sinks. Look for 304 stainless and brass or metal locknuts.
  • Plastic or ABS: inexpensive and won’t corrode, but threads can strip if overtightened and the finish wears faster.

Also think about the basket. Post-style baskets let you drop or lift the stopper with one hand, while twist-lock and spring baskets are easy to clean. Matching the strainer finish to your faucet gives the sink a finished look; see our best kitchen faucets guide if you’re updating both.

How to remove a stuck kitchen sink strainer

Old strainer locknuts are often corroded in place. Spray penetrating oil on the threads and wait 15 minutes. Then use a sink drain wrench, or tap a lug of the locknut counterclockwise with a hammer and flat screwdriver. If the whole strainer spins, have a helper hold it from above by placing the handles of pliers through the crossbars and a screwdriver between them for leverage. As a last resort, carefully cut through the locknut with a hacksaw or oscillating tool, taking care not to damage the sink.

Tools and materials

  • New kitchen sink strainer assembly
  • Sink drain wrench or large tongue-and-groove pliers
  • Plumber’s putty (non-staining for stone or composite sinks) or silicone, per the manufacturer
  • Putty knife, rag and mild cleaner
  • Bucket and towels
  • Hammer and flat screwdriver (to loosen a stuck locknut)
  • New tailpiece washer if needed

How to replace a kitchen sink strainer step by step

Step 1: Disconnect the drain

Clear the cabinet, place a bucket under the sink and loosen the slip nut connecting the tailpiece to the strainer. Remove the tailpiece, or the trap if it’s in the way. For details on traps, see how to replace a sink P-trap.

Step 2: Remove the locknut

Hold the strainer still from above (a helper with pliers through the basket crossbars helps), then unscrew the large locknut counterclockwise with a sink drain wrench. If it’s stuck, place a flat screwdriver against one of the nut’s lugs and tap it counterclockwise with a hammer. For retainer-style strainers, loosen the three screws instead.

Step 3: Remove the old strainer

Remove the locknut, friction ring and rubber gasket, then push the strainer body up out of the sink.

Step 4: Clean the sink opening

Scrape off all old putty and residue with a plastic putty knife, then clean and dry the area. A clean surface is essential for a watertight seal.

Step 5: Apply putty

Roll plumber’s putty into a rope about 1/2 inch thick and press it around the underside of the new strainer’s flange. Use non-staining putty for stone and composite sinks, or the sealant the manufacturer recommends.

Step 6: Install the new strainer

Press the strainer firmly into the sink opening. From below, slide on the rubber gasket, then the friction ring (often paper or plastic), then thread on the locknut by hand. Tighten with the drain wrench while a helper keeps the strainer from turning. Excess putty will squeeze out above.

Step 7: Reconnect and clean up

Reattach the tailpiece with a new washer and hand-tighten the slip nut plus a quarter turn. Wipe away excess putty around the flange inside the sink.

Step 8: Test for leaks

Close the basket and fill the sink with a few inches of water. Check for drips under the sink, then open the drain and watch the connections as it empties. Tighten slightly if needed.

Best kitchen sink strainer parts and tools

Best overall strainer

1. KOHLER K-8801-CP Duostrainer with Tailpiece

A solid brass kitchen sink strainer with a tailpiece and open/close basket.

  • Fits3-1/2 or 4 in sink outlets
  • MaterialSolid brass
  • Connection1-1/2 in with 4 in tailpiece
  • BasketRemovable, open/close stopper
  • FinishPolished chrome
  • BrandKOHLER

Pros

  • Durable solid brass
  • Tight-sealing stopper
  • Tailpiece included

Cons

  • Costs more than basic strainers
  • Heavier to install
Check price on Amazon
Like the KOHLER K-8801-CP Duostrainer with Tailpiece?Check price on Amazon
Best budget strainer

2. VARNAHOME Stainless Steel Twist-Lock Basket Drain Assembly

A 304 stainless steel strainer assembly with brass nuts and a twist-lock basket.

  • Fits3-1/2 to 4 in drains
  • Material304 stainless steel
  • NutsBrass
  • BasketTwist-lock seal and strainer
  • BrandVARNAHOME
  • UseKitchen sinks

Pros

  • Corrosion resistant
  • Good value
  • Plug and strainer in one

Cons

  • Fit and finish vary
  • Check tailpiece needs
Check price on Amazon
Like the VARNAHOME Stainless Steel Twist-Lock Basket Drain Assembly?Check price on Amazon
Best wrench

3. DURATECH Universal Sink Drain Wrench

An aluminum wrench for hex nuts and tab locknuts on sink strainers.

  • FitsHex nuts and 4, 6, 8-tab locknuts
  • MaterialAluminum alloy
  • UseSink strainers, shower drains
  • HandleErgonomic
  • BrandDURATECH
  • BenefitWorks in tight spaces

Pros

  • Fits most strainer nuts
  • Light and durable
  • Makes the job much easier

Cons

  • Single-purpose tool
  • May not fit unusual nuts
Check price on Amazon
Like the DURATECH Universal Sink Drain Wrench?Check price on Amazon
Best putty

4. Oatey 31177 Plumber’s Putty

A non-staining plumber’s putty for sealing sink strainers.

  • Size9 oz
  • TypePlumber’s putty
  • StainNon-staining formula
  • Safe onGranite, marble, quartz
  • UseStrainers, drains, deck plates
  • BrandOatey

Pros

  • Safe on stone sinks
  • Stays flexible
  • Easy cleanup

Cons

  • Not for pressurized connections
  • Some sinks require silicone instead
Check price on Amazon
Like the Oatey 31177 Plumber’s Putty?Check price on Amazon

Troubleshooting a leaking kitchen sink strainer

Leak locationFix
Around the strainer body under the sinkLocknut loose or putty failed; remove, clean and reinstall
At the tailpiece connectionTighten slip nut; replace the washer
Water drains when basket is closedBasket seal worn; replace basket or strainer
Strainer spins when tighteningHave a helper hold it from above with pliers

How to keep your kitchen sink strainer working

Empty the basket after each use, and rinse it with hot soapy water. Avoid pouring grease down the drain, which builds up under the basket and in the trap. Every few months, check under the sink for moisture around the strainer body. If you want a better basket for everyday use, see our best sink strainer picks, and if your drain is slow, our guide on clearing a clogged sink drain trap can help.

Kitchen sink strainer FAQs

How do I know what size kitchen sink strainer to buy?

Most kitchen sinks have a 3-1/2 inch drain opening and need a strainer with a 1-1/2 inch outlet. Measure the opening to confirm.

Should I use plumber’s putty or silicone on a sink strainer?

Most strainers use plumber’s putty. Use non-staining putty for stone sinks, or silicone if the sink or strainer manufacturer requires it.

How long does it take to replace a kitchen sink strainer?

Usually about one hour, longer if the old locknut is corroded.

Why is my kitchen sink strainer leaking?

Common causes are failed putty, a loose locknut, a worn gasket or a loose tailpiece connection.

Can I replace a kitchen sink strainer without a special wrench?

Yes, with large tongue-and-groove pliers or a hammer and screwdriver to turn the locknut, but a sink drain wrench makes it much easier.

Can a garbage disposal be installed instead of a strainer?

Yes. A disposal uses its own sink flange in place of the strainer; follow the disposal’s instructions.

Final thoughts

Replacing a kitchen sink strainer is a simple, inexpensive way to stop under-sink leaks and restore a sink that holds water. Clean the sink opening thoroughly, use the right putty, tighten the locknut while someone holds the strainer and check carefully for leaks. A quality brass or stainless strainer will last for years.

Check price on Amazon

Sabreen

Written by Sabreen

Sabreen writes the how-to guides and tips at Kitchen Bath Picks. Have a question, or spotted something out of date? Get in touch.